Devin Neal vs David Montgomery: Comparative Analysis of Performance and Potential

Devin Neal vs David Montgomery: Fantasy Football RB2 Analysis

The RB2 position in fantasy football is crucial for consistent scoring. While top RB1s like Jonathan Taylor capture attention, RB2s often provide steady points and are vital for roster depth. This week, the focus shifts to comparing Devin Neal and David Montgomery to identify who holds better fantasy value.

The Case for Devin Neal

Devin Neal recently stepped in as the Saints’ lead running back. In his last outing, he had 14 attempts with a 54% share, rushing for 47 yards against a middling Dolphins run defense. Neal’s yards per carry average was 3.4, closely aligning with the Saints’ overall average of 3.6 yards. The team’s running touchdown production remains low, with only three on the season, which limits Neal’s upside.

Neal projects as a flex option with RB2 potential due to his expected volume and receiving opportunities comparable to Alvin Kamara, who is currently ranked RB41. This week, the Saints face the Buccaneers, who rank sixth in rushing yards allowed but are more vulnerable to running backs in the receiving game, conceding 56.8 yards per game. This matchup favors Neal’s receiving upside.

The Case for David Montgomery

David Montgomery has appeared in 12 games, logging 123 carries for 543 yards and six touchdowns. His 4.3 yards per attempt and RB22 ranking place him as a low-end RB2 option. Despite a desire from Lions coach Dan Campbell to increase Montgomery’s workload, he has had single-digit carries in recent games, overshadowed by Jahmyr Gibbs.

The Lions face the Cowboys on Thursday night, a defense that allows average rushing yardage and ranks 20th against running backs. Both teams enter the game well-rested, suggesting a moderate outlook for Montgomery’s performance.

Start ‘Em Sit ‘Em: Who to Start This Week

Though Neal may command a larger share of his offense’s touches, his team’s overall struggles may limit his fantasy ceiling. Neal might receive 10-12 carries with around 60% of attempts, similar to Montgomery’s 30-40% touches producing comparable carries. Montgomery’s higher yards per carry and more reliable red zone opportunities make him the safer RB2 candidate.

1. Neal: Greater volume, weaker offense, potential for receiving yards
2. Montgomery: Lower volume, stronger offense, more touchdowns

Given these factors, David Montgomery offers a safer floor and more dependable upside for fantasy managers this week. Starting Montgomery is recommended for those seeking stability in their RB2 spot.