The Incoherence of Ken Burns’s ‘The American Revolution’
Ken Burns’s six-part documentary series, The American Revolution, attempts to retell the founding story of the United States by weaving together multiple perspectives. However, the series struggles with coherence as it tries to reconcile the polarized views of history in today’s political landscape. Burns aims to present a respectful account of the mainstream consensus, but that consensus has fractured and politicized, leaving the narrative disjointed and unclear.
The documentary presents three intersecting narratives: the military history of the War for Independence, the experiences of African American slaves seeking freedom, and the plight of Native Americans fighting to preserve sovereignty. These storylines illustrate the deep divisions within colonial society, challenging the traditional view of a unified revolutionary effort. A featured historian points out that the Revolution was less a unified uprising and more a civil war, highlighting internal conflicts and ongoing struggles over freedom and identity.
Burns’s sympathetic approach honors the courage of people on all sides without fully committing to what the Revolution ultimately achieved. The Patriots’ military campaigns receive detailed coverage, but the film glosses over the profound political innovations that established a democratic republic based on popular sovereignty. This omission leaves a gap in understanding the true significance of the Revolution beyond its battles.
Key moments of historical complexity, such as Washington’s leadership through setbacks and the treaty consequences for Native Americans and escaped slaves, are covered honestly but without resolution. The film is careful to depict the harsh realities faced by marginalized groups, yet it refrains from drawing definitive conclusions about the legacy of the founders or the meaning of “all men are created equal.”
The narrative concludes on an ambiguous note, highlighting the unfinished nature of the American Revolution. Burns’s series reflects a nation still deeply divided over its history and ideals. As the documentary suggests, the story of the Revolution—and America’s quest for unity—remains ongoing.
-
-
-
-
