The Lumbee Tribe of North Carolina is on the verge of gaining federal recognition following the recent passage of the National Defense Authorization Act by the Senate. This legislative milestone marks a significant breakthrough after decades of efforts by the tribe to secure official status as a federally recognized tribal nation.
The Lumbee Tribe has long pursued recognition, a status that grants access to vital federal resources such as Indian Health Service, federal grants, and the ability to place land into trust. Tribal member Charles Graham described the moment as “very, very emotional,” emphasizing the pride and sovereignty the recognition would affirm for about 60,000 Lumbee citizens.
Historical and Political Background
Federal recognition processes for tribes involve strict evaluation by the Interior Department’s Office of Federal Acknowledgement. In the 1980s, the Lumbee’s application was denied due to a 1956 congressional act recognizing the tribe but withholding federal benefits. Although this decision was reversed in 2016, the Lumbee chose to focus on congressional recognition, gaining bipartisan political support, notably from former President Donald Trump. Trump’s campaign promise and subsequent executive order directing the Interior Department to develop a recognition plan played a critical role in advancing the issue.
Controversies and Challenges
The recognition effort faces opposition within Native American communities. Critics argue that the Lumbee’s heritage claims are inconsistent and lack sufficient documentation, cautioning against political expediency overriding historical verification. Shawnee Tribe Chief Ben Barnes warned that “if identity becomes a matter of assertion rather than continuity,” it undermines the integrity of federal recognition.
Nevertheless, the Lumbee emphasize their descent from diverse ancestral groups, including Algonquian, Iroquoian, and Siouan language families, and highlight over a century of state recognition since 1885. The tribe’s political influence in Robeson County, a key swing region in North Carolina, further amplifies its strategic importance.
Financial and Social Impact
The Congressional Budget Office estimates the federal support required for the Lumbee Tribe would reach hundreds of millions of dollars in the initial years. Experts like Kevin Washburn urge careful allocation of federal appropriations to ensure that other tribal nations do not suffer funding shortages because of the expanded recognition.
Lumbee members celebrated the Senate vote in Pembroke, North Carolina, with jubilant gatherings, hopeful the final congressional approval will soon affirm their status. This recognition would place the Lumbee among the nation’s largest tribal entities, unlocking historic opportunities for cultural preservation and economic development.
Read more at: www.pbs.org
