Palm Beach recently gained a new claim to reality TV fame with Netflix’s release of Members Only: Palm Beach. This reality series profiles five women navigating the social and philanthropic scenes in the region, promising drama and exclusivity. However, the representation of Palm Beach in the show has sparked mixed reactions among local residents.
Contrary to the show’s title, much of the series was filmed outside the actual Town of Palm Beach, primarily in Palm Beach County and its neighboring areas. Locals point out that the series largely depicts life in West Palm Beach or other parts of the county rather than the affluent island town renowned for its elite reputation.
Local Perspectives on Authenticity
Todd Michael Glaser, a prominent Palm Beach developer, expressed a sense of disappointment about the show’s location choices, likening the experience to "ordering Coca-Cola and getting Fanta." This sentiment reflects a broader skepticism about the show’s claim to represent Palm Beach’s core social fabric accurately.
Similarly, island resident Ryan Williams distanced himself from the show’s portrayal, jokingly referring to the cast members as people from Boca Raton, a different part of South Florida. This response highlights a territorial distinction within affluent communities that matters greatly to residents.
Palm Beach Identity: Beyond the Reality TV Lens
Palm Beach’s identity is complex and multifaceted, spanning generations of billionaires, philanthropists, influencers, and professionals. According to Kim Murstein, a part-time resident and cultural commentator, "There isn’t one version of a Palm Beach person," emphasizing social diversity beyond traditional stereotypes.
Despite the town’s strict regulations on businesses and filming, Palm Beach’s broader reputation continues to attract attention. The release of the Netflix show coincides with heightened public interest due to high-profile estates and the presence of Mar-a-Lago, which further cements the area’s allure on the national stage.
Regional Expansion and Branding Confusion
The use of “Palm Beach” as a brand extends beyond the island itself. Some West Palm Beach residents market their locale as “Palm Beach West,” while others opt for Palm Beach mailing addresses to enhance prestige. Philanthropist Jean Shafiroff compared this to how the Hamptons name expanded to include multiple communities, diluting a once narrowly defined identity.
Businesses off the island also leverage the Palm Beach name, as seen with "Mary Lou’s," a nightclub located in West Palm Beach but branded as “Mary Lou’s Palm Beach.” This trend illustrates how the region’s brand has evolved into a symbol of status beyond strict geographic boundaries.
Contrasts Within the Show
The cast of Members Only reflects a range of backgrounds including hospitality executives, developers, and creatives, but their standing within Palm Beach’s elite circles has been questioned. Key Palm Beach social hubs like Sant Ambroeus and Mar-a-Lago receive little attention, while venues in Jupiter and West Palm Beach feature prominently.
These details underscore the disconnect between the series’ narrative and the entrenched social hierarchy on the island. Cameron Silver, a former reality star and local curator, acknowledges residents’ concerns about the show but adds that Palm Beach’s mystique is already exposed through other means, such as widespread media coverage of Mar-a-Lago.
Implications for Palm Beach’s Image
Palm Beach maintains strict zoning and cultural preservation rules, including prohibiting chain restaurants to protect its unique character. These measures influence how entertainment productions approach filming on the island and may explain why Members Only filmed mainly off-island.
Todd Michael Glaser worries that the show’s dramatic flavor contrasts sharply with more refined portrayals like Apple TV’s Palm Royale. He notes the shift from glamour and elegance to louder, more ostentatious depictions outlined by flashy cars and gaudy fashion.
Social Geography of the Series
West Palm Beach plays a significant role in the series because of cast member residency, yet many Palm Beach elites reportedly seldom visit or engage with the city. This geographic and social divide is exemplified by Silver’s remark about his Palm Beach friends’ unfamiliarity with how to reach West Palm Beach, illustrating a clear boundary in lifestyle and social circles.
Netflix’s attempt to tap into Palm Beach’s glamorous cachet is understandable given the area’s association with wealth and exclusivity. Still, locals’ responses suggest the show falls short of accurately embodying the town’s authentic social scene and cultural nuances.
Read more at: www.townandcountrymag.com-
-
-
-
