US online used car retailer Carvana experienced a sharp decline in its share price following a critical report released by short seller Gotham City Research. The report raised concerns over related-party transactions involving Carvana’s family-controlled affiliates, notably highlighting significant cash burn by DriveTime Automotive.
Shares of Carvana dropped by as much as 13 percent shortly after Gotham disclosed its findings. The short seller presented financial documents indicating that DriveTime, a privately held sister company controlled by the Garcia family, had depleted approximately $1 billion in cash across 2023 and 2024. This period coincides with Carvana’s recent pivot toward profitability.
Allegations Against Family-Controlled Entities
Gotham City Research’s report focused on transactions between Carvana and entities tied to the Garcia family, which owns and operates both Carvana and DriveTime. Carvana was originally spun off from DriveTime, and Ernie Garcia II holds a substantial stake in both businesses, creating potential conflicts of interest.
According to the report, Carvana and DriveTime also rely on a third Garcia-controlled firm, Bridgecrest, to manage customer loans. These loans are later securitized and sold to investors. Gotham criticized the financial structure, pointing out that DriveTime’s $4.3 billion debt load increased by $800 million in 2024 as it financed ongoing cash losses.
Context of Previous Short Seller Attacks
This latest scrutiny revives earlier controversies that surfaced when Hindenburg Research targeted Carvana in a report last year. Hindenburg accused Carvana of engaging in misleading accounting practices involving DriveTime. Carvana firmly denied those claims, emphasizing its transparency and labeling the accusations as attempts to drive down its stock price.
Carvana narrowly averted bankruptcy in 2022, suffering a drastic share price collapse to $4 before recovering dramatically to $473 following creditor agreements and cost-cutting measures. The company’s financial turnaround was notable, achieving positive adjusted earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation, and amortization (EBITDA) of $1.4 billion in 2024.
Financial and Industry Implications
Gotham’s findings raise broader questions about the stability of credit and financial risk within the US used car market. Industry observers have highlighted vulnerabilities, underscored by recent difficulties faced by suppliers such as First Brands and Tricolor.
DriveTime’s substantial debt accumulation amid cash flow challenges highlights tensions between aggressive growth strategies and sustainable financial management. Analysts are now closely watching whether Carvana’s recent profitability is resilient or masks underlying operational risks.
Key Points from Gotham City Research Report
- DriveTime burned through $1 billion in cash over the past two years despite its close ties to Carvana.
- Debt at DriveTime increased by $800 million to $4.3 billion in 2024 to support operations.
- Carvana’s financial health is intertwined with related-party loans and securitization via Bridgecrest.
- Previous short seller allegations from Hindenburg accused Carvana of “sham” deals with DriveTime, which Carvana rejects.
- The situation underscores risks regarding consumer credit quality in the automotive finance sector.
Carvana had not issued an immediate response to Gotham’s latest report at the time of publication. Investors and market participants will likely await further clarifications as questions about governance and financial transparency remain central to the stock’s outlook.
Read more at: www.ft.com
