The Pentagon is influencing significant policy changes in Scouting America, particularly targeting transgender youths. Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth announced that the organization will now require members to identify based on their biological sex at birth rather than gender identity.
Applications for membership will only include “male” or “female” options, and the chosen option must align with the applicant’s birth certificate. Under these policies, youths assigned opposite sexes at birth cannot share bathrooms, tents, or other communal spaces within the organization.
These shifts come as part of the Pentagon’s broader campaign against diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) initiatives, which it labels as “woke culture.” Hegseth stated the military will “vigorously review” Scouting America’s compliance and may withdraw support if the organization does not meet these new requirements.
Some changes mirror proposals from Scouting America made earlier this year. These include eliminating the Citizenship in Society merit badge, launching a Military Service merit badge, and waiving registration fees for children of military personnel.
Despite the rollback on transgender policies, Scouting America reaffirmed its new name and commitment to female members. The group continues to serve over 200,000 girls through its programs, reflecting its inclusion of females since 2018 in Cub Scouts and since 2019 in its flagship Scouts BSA program.
Historically, Scouting America has progressively expanded membership eligibility. It allowed gay youths starting in 2013 and lifted its ban on gay adult leaders in 2015. The organization adopted transgender inclusion policies in 2017, prior to the current Pentagon-driven policy reversals.
The Pentagon’s critique centers on Scouting America’s recent social justice and gender inclusion stances. A statement from the Defense Department accused the organization of “embracing DEI and gender-fluid ideological stances” inconsistent with current administration values.
Dating back to 1937, the military has maintained strong ties with the Boy Scouts, including logistical support for the National Boy Scout Jamboree. Many Eagle Scouts pursue military service, making scouting a significant pathway into the U.S. armed forces.
In response to Pentagon pressure, Scouting America proposed several reforms. Alongside merit badge changes, the organization plans a rededication ceremony to emphasize leadership, duty to God, country, and service, while dissolving its DEI board committee.
The Boy Scouts of America, founded in 1910, has undergone major transformations amid cultural shifts and legal challenges. The U.S. Supreme Court upheld exclusion of gay members in 1992, a ban lifted two decades later. The organization also faced a flood of sexual abuse claims and entered bankruptcy proceedings.
Despite controversies, Scouting America reported a membership increase of about 16,000 participants recently, reaching just over 1 million members. Its CEO Roger Krone described the rebranding and gender-neutral naming as generating increased public interest.
The Pentagon’s evolving relationship with Scouting America highlights the tension between longstanding military partnerships and contemporary debates about gender identity and inclusion. Future interactions will rely on the organization’s adherence to the Pentagon’s mandated core value reforms.
Read more at: www.pbs.org
